Pit Boss Vs Blackstone Griddle
If you are searching for a top-notch outdoor cooker, you may have considered two of the biggest names in the market – Pit Boss Vs Blackstone Griddle. While both manufacturing companies offer a range of grills, smokers, and pizza ovens with exceptional construction and heating mechanisms, selecting one can be challenging.
However, the griddle has become a popular cooking option for many, as it can cook various foods like eggs and pancakes that a grill cannot. If you are still determining which brand to opt for, fret not. We have comprehensively compared Pit Boss vs Blackstone to help you make an informed decision.
Blackstone: What You Must Know About The Company
Blackstone has been leading the griddle business for an extensive period with its exceptional expertise in crafting high-quality griddles and flat tops.
From tabletop models with one burner to full-sized griddles ideal for backyard cooking, Blackstone offers unique sizes to satisfy everyone’s needs. Each product is exclusively designed in the US and shipped worldwide, making Blackstone the household name you can trust.
Therefore, for the best griddles and flat tops in the industry, you don’t need to look any further than Blackstone.
Pit Boss: What You Must Know About The Company
Pit Boss offers an extensive range of high-quality griddles, complemented by a wide selection of other products, including pellet, charcoal, and gas grills, along with their accessories.
Whether looking for a standalone, compact, portable, or traditional griddle, Pit Boss covers all your outdoor cooking needs.
Plus, with options ideal for camping and other outdoor experiences, you’ll always be set for your next adventure.
Pit Boss Vs Blackstone Griddle: A Comparison Of Various Features
We kick off our showdown between Blackstone and Pit Boss griddles by pitting their tabletop models against each other. For those who are really into cooking yet lack space or don’t want to hurt their wallets, these units are a superb choice.
Tabletop griddles are a light and compact option offering a blend of cooking space and affordability. They take up less room and provide vast versatility and optimal functionality.
In this group, we present the Blackstone 1666 Tabletop Griddle and the Pit Boss PB336GS Tabletop Gas Griddle.
-Compare Brands
When searching for the perfect griddle, it’s easy to feel lost when looking at the numerous brands on the market. To avoid this, it’s important to consider each option’s reputation, price, and essential features before concluding.
Fortunately, two brands that consistently impress are Blackstone and Pit Boss Griddles, both of which have a fantastic reputation in the industry. With their top-notch quality and reliable performance, it’s hard to go wrong with either option.
-Choose the Size
Selecting a suitable heating unit depends on various factors, including your space and requirements.
Larger units provide energy-saving capabilities and flexibility through multiple heat zones. However, bigger is only sometimes better, so choose the unit that aligns with your needs.
-Construction
The construction is a critical factor to consider. A flimsy griddle will not withstand the wear and tear of rough conditions, weather changes, and high temperatures.
Thankfully, Pit Boss and Blackstone offer griddles made from high-quality materials. Pit Boss manufactures cast iron and stainless steel griddles, while Blackstone uses only stainless steel.
Both these companies ensure their griddles are sturdy enough to last for a substantial period.
Whether hosting a barbecue party, camping, or tailgating, Pit Boss and Blackstone griddles will be effective. Pit Boss is an excellent option if you’re looking for a cast iron griddle.
However, if you prefer stainless steel, both companies are equally reliable.
-Surface Area
Cooking needs are unique to each individual. A medium-sized griddle with adequate cooking surface area is enough for family living. But, a big griddle with a large surface area is crucial if you’re running a restaurant. The surface area determines the amount of food you can cook at once.
Blackstone, the largest griddle, offers close to 720 square inches of surface area, enough to feed an entire restaurant without any issues. In contrast, the largest Pit Boss griddle provides only close to 673 square inches, making Blackstone ideal if you need a bigger surface area.
The material used to make the plate must be considered when purchasing a griddle. Cast iron, aluminum, and different types of steel are available. Besides ease of cleaning, plate material is vital in ensuring even heating. Choose a quality griddle that is built to last and easy to clean.
-Temperature Control
One of the most important things to consider when purchasing a grill is the level of control you have over the heat zones. This is an issue with several models from Pit Boss, as they are not equipped with controllable heat zones.
As a result, you may find an uneven temperature across the cooking surface. However, Blackstone griddles address this concern with controllable heat zones allowing independent burner control.
This feature proves to be a significant advantage when cooking various types of food simultaneously.
By controlling each burner, you can ensure every item is cooked to perfection, no matter where it’s located on the griddle. So, for a more precise and even cooking experience, Blackstone griddles are an excellent choice.
-Cooking Experience
When investing in a griddle, the following features are pivotal for an ideal cooking experience: individual burners, cooking systems, and the ability to adjust the temperature. Among the many options, Blackstone and Pit Boss griddles are two of the best.
Blackstone griddles are perfect for whipping breakfasts, vegetables, and much more. While cooking thick meat requires a learning curve, you’re good to go once you get the hang of it. The only downside is that the surface is stainless steel, which could be better for thick cuts of meat.
On the other hand, Pit Boss griddles are the answer to your meat-grilling needs. They feature cast-iron plates that ensure equal and consistent heat distribution for thoroughly cooked meat.
Blackstone is your go-to if you want to keep things light by making breakfasts, hot dogs, pancakes, and more. However, if your priority is to grill various meat cuts, then Pit Boss would be an excellent addition to your cooking arsenal.
-Maintenance And Cleanliness
To achieve optimum results and make mouth-watering meals, proper maintenance and cleaning of your griddle are crucial, regardless of your chosen brand. The Blackstone and Pit Boss griddles feature a grease catcher and hole on the surface, and they’re also effortless to clean. Use a metal scraper to clean the grease, and let the hole catch any debris.
Afterward, clean the surface, leaving no particles or food remnants behind. Regardless of which model you select, conducting proper research is essential to determine the best way to clean it. Plus, both Blackstone and Pit Boss griddles require similar maintenance and care.
Furthermore, seasoning your griddle is vital to ensure a non-stick surface, guaranteeing even heating and scrumptious meals. Taking proper care of your griddle means it’ll last you for an extended period, and clean-up is simple and hassle-free – ensuring enjoyable meals every time.
-The Price
Both Pit Boss and Blackstone offer many options, but how do they compare in their respective price ranges?
Blackstone griddles range from $199 to $500 for those on a budget, while Pit Boss can cost upwards of $650. While Pit Boss may have higher price tags, it’s important to note that this is usually due to its advanced technology and extra features. Nevertheless, comparing similar models is the best way to gauge the value of the griddle and determine which is the ultimate winner.
For instance, in this comparison, let’s look at the Pit Boss flat-top grill and the Blackstone. Both are very similar in pricing, with Pit Boss retailing at $449 and Blackstone being a bit cheaper and often on sale (check prices for both). In this case, the edge goes to Blackstone in terms of affordability.
While pricing can vary based on features and added technology, Pit Boss pellet grills tend to be pricier than Blackstone griddles. However, pellet grills are known for their modern technology and added features, which could be worth the extra cost for some buyers.
-Versatility
Understanding the versatility of griddles is key when choosing the right brand. Each brand offers unique advantages, from the number of burners to the surface area.
Cooking on a griddle is a versatile experience, allowing you to whip up breakfast, lunch, and dinner meals. While there may be certain limitations depending on the model, you can always refer to the manual to discover the best types of foods to cook on your chosen griddle.
If you’re looking to cook thick cuts of meat, the Pit Boss is an excellent choice, as it saves you time while delivering delicious results. Alternatively, the Blackstone excels at sautéing veggies and is perfect for whipping up pancakes, eggs, sausages, and more.
-Cooking Area
One of the biggest points of comparison is the amount of cooking space they provide.
This is crucial because ample space allows for temperature control and different cooking zones.
The Blackstone griddle model, at 36″, offers 720 square inches of flat top grilling space.
However, the Pit Boss griddle takes the crown in this category with 753 square inches of cooking space. If you need extra room for your cooking, the Pit Boss might be the way to go.
-Features
The Pit Boss versus Blackstone griddle debate has been raging on for ages. Here’s the rundown: the basic Pit Boss model has no frills, but its Gen 2 griddles are top-notch.
However, the base model lost features like side shelves that exceeded the Deluxe model’s price to $569. But Pit Boss has a cool turn-to-start ignition feature that simplifies the cooking process.
The Blackstone basic model has an impressive list of features:
- A non-foldable side shelf
- A neat side shelf with a removable cutting board
- A paper towel holder
- Garbage bag hooks
That’s amazing for your prep work!
Both brands have a grease management system, but Blackstone wins extra points for its rear grease management system. Meanwhile, Pit Boss’ grease management system is found in the front.
-Reliability
Both Blackstone and Pit Boss boast significant followings and receive high consumer praise, albeit with a few negative comments.
The Pit Boss griddle emerges victorious in terms of warranty, as it comes with a 2-year coverage, whereas Blackstone’s warranty stands at a year.
Choose Pit Boss to have an exceptional cooking experience with added peace of mind from a longer warranty!
-Ease of Cleaning
Selecting a griddle with an easy-to-clean material is key to optimize your time for important tasks. Look no further than Blackstone and Pit Boss griddle, whose grease management systems make clean-up a breeze. Say goodbye to tedious maintenance, and hello to more efficient cooking!
Blackstone vs Pit Boss Griddle: Which is Better?
Choosing between Blackstone and Pit Boss griddles can be daunting as you want to secure the best deal and avoid regretting your purchase.
To help you make an informed decision, let’s compare two highly reputable griddles from both brands: the Blackstone 1666 Tabletop Griddle and the Pit Boss PB336GS Table Top LP Gas Griddle.
-Cooking Performance
Blackstone griddles are renowned for their powerful heating capabilities. With a larger cooking surface than Pit Boss, food can be prepared more efficiently and evenly, making meal prep a breeze.
Boasting a whopping 24,000 BTUs, Blackstone cooks food faster than Pit Boss, which only produces up to 18,000 BTUs.
And if you manage to snag a Blackstone model with a hood, your meals will be the envy of all your friends! The hood ensures even heat distribution, delivering perfectly cooked food every time.
-Design and Build
The Pit Boss and Blackstone griddles are hot commodities for outdoor enthusiasts who love to cook up a storm while camping.
Pit Boss measures a sleek 20.47 × 17.32 × 10.83 inches and weighs an easy-to-carry 27 pounds. Meanwhile, Blackstone weighs in at 32 pounds and measures a slightly larger 22.5 × 19 × 9 inches. Both made of sturdy stainless steel, these griddles boast ample cooking space, but what sets them apart?
Pit Boss’s grease trap is at the side, while Blackstone’s is at the rear. Pit Boss also lacks a hood option, whereas Blackstone has covered and uncovered variants. Regardless, these griddles can handle high temperatures and withstand outdoor elements, so you can always expect a delicious meal no matter where you are.
-Cleaning and Maintenance
Ensuring a well-seasoned cooking surface makes cleaning either Blackstone or Pit Boss griddles a breeze. Scrape away any stuck-on bits with a spatula or scraper. Unlike the Blackstone, the Pit Boss’s grease tray is at the back and lacks a handle. Season your griddles once more after cleaning with soap and water before reusing them.
FAQs About Pit Boss Vs Blackstone Griddle
How Much Does The Pit Boss And Blackstone Riddles Weigh?
The Pit Boss PB336GS Table Top LP Gas Griddle weighs 27 pounds, while the Blackstone 1666 Tabletop Griddle weighs 32 pounds.
Can You Cook With The Lid Down On A Blackstone Griddle?
Yes, you can cook with the lid down on a Blackstone griddle. This allows for even heat distribution and better cooking results.
Which Is Better For Outdoor Cooking: Pit Boss Or Blackstone?
Both Pit Boss and Blackstone are excellent choices for outdoor cooking. They excel at preparing delicious meals with their stainless steel construction, powerful heating capabilities, and ample cooking space. Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference and budget.
Which Has The Better Grease Management System: Pit Boss Or Blackstone?
Blackstone has a rear grease management system, while Pit Boss is at the front. This makes it easier for you to clean up after cooking on a Blackstone griddle. However, it ultimately depends on your preference.
Which Has The Longer Warranty: Pit Boss Or Blackstone?
Pit Boss griddles come with a 2-year warranty, whereas Blackstone’s is 1-year. This makes Pit Boss the clear winner in terms of warranty coverage.
Which Has The Larger Cooking Area: Pit Boss Or Blackstone?
Blackstone has a larger cooking area than Pit Boss, with 753 square inches of cooking space versus Pit Boss’ 604.5 square inches. This makes it easier to prepare large meals for family and friends.
Final Thoughts: Pit Boss Vs Blackstone Griddle
If you love outdoor cooking, a griddle is an excellent tool. You can cook various foods simultaneously with a larger cooking surface and adjustable heat zones.
But with so many available options, how do you decide which one to buy? In this post, we’ve compared two of the most popular brands, Blackstone vs Pit Boss, to help you make an informed decision.
Both Blackstone and Pit Boss produce great griddles, so it ultimately comes down to your needs. We compared the basic models, but check out their other options if you have a bigger budget. For example, the Pit Boss Ultimate Griddle series boasts a sleek look and more features and can even be lifted off the cart for portability. Meanwhile, the Blackstone Patio Series or extensive outdoor kitchen line offers all your desired features.
But what about the basic models we compared? Well, we have to give the edge to the Pit Boss. Its additional surface area, warranty, and lower price make it the best choice. However, if you’re leaning towards the Blackstone or want to learn more, check out our 5 Things to Know Before Buying guide.
Once you’ve decided, remember to grab the basic accessories you need to use your new griddle. Both Pit Boss and Blackstone offer a 5-piece griddle accessory kit with two bottles, two spatulas, and a scraper, all you need to get started.
Choosing the right griddle depends on your budget, needs, and preferences. Hopefully, this post has helped you make an informed decision so you can enjoy your griddle for years to come.
Pitmaster Lives in Eugene, USA. Bio: I’m Billy McCallum, and I love barbecue. I’m the president and founder of Billy Mac’s Bar & Grill, with over 20 years of experience in the field. I’m an exceptional pitmaster and grill expert who uses charcoal, wood, and fire to craft extraordinary culinary masterpieces. My mission is to educate others how to master their grills and cook a diverse range of foods on them. I have extensive expertise smoking briskets, pork shoulders using charcoal, wood, or propane grills/smokers.
I also review kitchent appliances such as grills, smoke, and more. I’ve tried out almost every model available, so if you’re in the market for any of these items be sure to check out my reviews!